A carnivore diet before and after story can be dramatic. Weight loss, fewer cravings, better energy, and calmer digestion are all reported in real-world experiences. You also see trade-offs and potential risks that are easy to miss on social media highlight reels. This guide walks you through what you might realistically expect before, during, and after trying a carnivore diet, using published case studies as a reference point.
What the carnivore diet actually is
At its core, a carnivore diet is an all-animal-food eating pattern. You focus on meat, fish, eggs, and sometimes dairy. Vegetables, fruit, grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds are either minimized or completely removed.
In some versions you eat only ruminant meat such as beef and lamb, plus salt and water. In others you include a wider range of animal foods like fish, shellfish, eggs, butter, and hard cheese. A nutritionist who ran a strict carnivore experiment in 2025 started with meat, fish, eggs, and fermented dairy for one month, then removed dairy and ate only red meat, liver, and eggs for several weeks after that (Chief Nutrition).
You will likely eat more protein and fat than you are used to and essentially zero carbs. That shift is what drives many of the before and after changes people notice.
Why people try carnivore in the first place
Understanding your own “before” helps you evaluate any “after.” People rarely switch to an all-meat diet out of curiosity alone. They usually arrive there after trying many other options.
Common reasons you might consider carnivore include:
- Weight loss that has stalled in spite of calorie counting
- Long-standing digestive issues like IBS, bloating, or SIBO
- Blood sugar or blood pressure that remains high on a standard diet
- Strong carbohydrate, sugar, or alcohol cravings
- Chronic pain, fatigue, or mood issues that have not responded to other diets
For example, a 54‑year‑old woman named Lynda lost 50 pounds on a 100 percent carnivore approach and reported overcoming 20 years of alcohol and sugar addiction within 30 days. She also noticed relief from severe menopause symptoms like hot flushes, night sweats, and stubborn belly weight once she prioritized protein over fat in her meals (The Primal).
Others come to carnivore with complex medical histories. One person dealing with severe IBS, mood disorders, and chronic pain reported complete remission of chronic symptoms and a 25 pound weight loss within 60 days of eliminating seed oils, vegetables, and salads and then following a carnivore diet while training for bodybuilding competitions (The Primal).
Before: what your starting point might look like
Your “before” snapshot might include several overlapping issues. Looking at case studies can help you notice patterns that sound familiar.
Weight, cravings, and energy
Many people start carnivore with:
- Weight gain or plateau despite eating “healthy”
- Intense evening cravings for snacks, sweets, or alcohol
- Afternoon energy crashes and brain fog
Lynda, for instance, struggled with weight gain around the midsection and intense sugar and alcohol cravings before going carnivore. Within a month of switching, she described those addictive patterns as dramatically reduced while her weight began to drop steadily (The Primal).
Digestive and gut health problems
IBS, SIBO, reflux, and general gut discomfort are another big “before” theme. You might notice:
- Bloating after most meals
- Alternating constipation and diarrhea
- Painful gas or cramping
- Heartburn or reflux that requires medication
One person with lifelong SIBO and insomnia, a kindergarten teacher in New York, used a carnivore diet as part of her healing approach. Before starting, she struggled to sleep through the night and felt exhausted in the early mornings. Within 90 days on carnivore, she reported that her SIBO symptoms had resolved and she was able to wake at 4:30 am feeling rested and energetic (The Primal).
Another case involved a person with IBS, mood disorders, and chronic pain who had tried many previous diets. Their “before” included daily gastrointestinal discomfort and low energy. After 60 days on carnivore, they reported both full remission of chronic symptoms and improved training capacity for bodybuilding (The Primal).
Metabolic and medication load
If you have multiple metabolic issues, your before picture may include:
- Elevated blood pressure
- High fasting blood sugar or prediabetes
- Cholesterol and triglyceride concerns
- A list of daily medications for overlapping conditions
In one case, an individual who started carnivore on September 1 weighed 187 pounds, had blood pressure readings around 190/104, and a blood glucose level of 8.7. Within 50 days of following a carnivore diet, their weight dropped to 177 pounds, blood pressure normalized to 124/69, and blood glucose reduced to 6.4. They were also able to discontinue five medications, including those for cholesterol, thyroid, GERD, IBS, and nerve pain, under medical supervision (The Primal).
These examples do not guarantee identical results for you, but they highlight what some people’s “before” looks like when they decide to experiment with carnivore.
During: what to expect in the first weeks
The transition period shapes a lot of your carnivore diet before and after impressions. You may feel worse before you feel better, especially if you come from a higher carb or plant-heavy diet.
Early adaptation and side effects
In the first one to three weeks, you might experience:
- Fatigue or “low gear” workouts
- Headaches or “keto flu” type symptoms
- Temporary digestive changes like constipation or loose stools
- Mood fluctuations or increased irritability
A nutritionist who followed a strict carnivore regimen in 2025 documented an initial dip in running performance. For the first few weeks, workouts felt harder and slower. After about three weeks, they reported clear fat adaptation. Endurance improved significantly, and they went on to complete a 50 km ultra-marathon feeling energetic with none of the usual post-race fatigue or digestive distress they had experienced previously (Chief Nutrition).
Hydration, electrolyte intake, and gradual transitions can make this adaptation smoother. If you switch overnight from a high carbohydrate diet to very low carb, you are more likely to feel the contrast.
Simple meals and practical benefits
One underrated “during” benefit is reduced decision fatigue around food. The same nutritionist noted that their strict carnivore phase, which included only meat, fish, eggs, and fermented dairy initially, saved both time and money on meal prep. Compared with buying organic vegetables, fruits, and a variety of plant-based products, sticking to a few animal foods simplified shopping and cooking and lowered overall food costs (Chief Nutrition).
You may find that:
- Grocery lists become shorter and more predictable
- Cooking takes less time and involves fewer recipes
- Eating out is simpler because your options are very clear
This simplicity can be appealing if you are busy and overwhelmed with meal planning.
After: physical changes you may notice
As weeks turn into months, the “after” side of a carnivore diet before and after story becomes more apparent. People highlight weight changes, lab markers, energy, and performance.
Weight and body composition
Weight loss is common, but not universal. Some people lose more fat; others notice weight redistribution or even small increases in both lean mass and fat depending on how they eat and move.
In a DEXA scan analysis over six weeks of carnivore, the 2025 nutritionist gained about 1 kilogram of lean muscle and 1.5 kilograms of fat. That meant a 2 percent increase in body fat and a slight increase in visceral fat, which raised questions given their previous history of osteopenia. They also saw a small decline in bone mineral density during that short period, which became a concern to monitor longer term (Chief Nutrition).
This highlights something important for your own expectations. Not every carnivore transformation will be dramatic weight loss alone. How much you eat, your activity level, and your starting point all matter. In contrast, Lynda saw a 50 pound weight loss, while another man who returned to carnivore after recovering from a serious car accident lost 30 pounds in roughly 2.5 months and reported lower daily pain and higher energy so he could be more active during recovery (The Primal).
Blood work and hormone markers
You might also notice changes in lab tests. In the nutritionist’s 2025 experiment, blood tests taken after five weeks on carnivore showed:
- Improved hormone profiles
- Better iron saturation levels
- Some elevated markers like liver enzymes and C-reactive protein
In that case, the liver and inflammation markers were partially attributed to a recent ultra-marathon. Multiple consulted doctors considered these results normal given the heavy training stress and context (Chief Nutrition).
If you have high blood pressure or blood sugar at baseline, you may see improvements there too, as in the case of the person who reduced blood pressure from 190/104 to 124/69 and lowered blood glucose from 8.7 to 6.4 in 50 days (The Primal). Any medication changes should always be done alongside your healthcare provider.
Gut microbiome shifts
One common concern with an all‑meat diet is what happens to your gut microbiome when you remove fiber. In the 2025 nutritionist experiment, gut microbiome analysis after four weeks on carnivore showed a shift from an unfavorable Firmicutes-dominated profile to a higher Bacteroidetes ratio. This was considered a more favorable pattern, and it occurred even without fermented vegetables or dietary fiber in the plan (Chief Nutrition).
This does not prove that all-fiber elimination is ideal for everyone, but it does suggest that your gut can adapt in ways that are not always negative. If you have severe IBS or SIBO, temporarily reducing fermentable plant foods can calm symptoms, which is what some of the individual success stories describe.
After: performance, pain, and daily life
Beyond scale and lab numbers, your day to day experience is where the carnivore diet before and after contrast often feels biggest.
Energy, sleep, and mood
Many people report steadier energy and fewer daily crashes once they adapt to using fat and ketones for fuel. The New York teacher with lifelong SIBO and insomnia moved from poor sleep and low morning energy to waking at 4:30 am feeling rested within 90 days on carnivore (The Primal).
Others note:
- Reduced anxiety or mood swings
- Lower mental chatter around food choices
- More predictable hunger and fewer sudden cravings
The person who used carnivore to address addictions described a sharp drop in sugar and alcohol cravings within 30 days. They framed protein intake as the anchor of their meals, which may have helped stabilize appetite and reduce the urge to binge (The Primal).
Athletic performance and recovery
If you train or compete, your performance is a big part of your “after.” The 50 km ultra-marathon case is a clear example. After the initial adaptation phase, the runner felt strong throughout the race, reported no usual post‑event fatigue, and had no digestive distress that they had previously experienced with higher carb fueling (Chief Nutrition).
Another individual who had a severe car accident and spent nine months in recovery returned to a carnivore diet and lost 30 pounds in about 2.5 months. Along with weight loss, they described eliminating the need for daily pain medication and experiencing dramatically reduced pain and increased energy, which supported more movement during rehab (The Primal).
These stories suggest that once adapted, you can maintain or even improve endurance and recovery, but you should expect a transition period when workouts feel harder.
Risks, limitations, and what the stories do not show
Real carnivore diet before and after stories are inspiring, but they also have limits. Most of the reports are short term, typically 30 to 90 days, and often involve motivated individuals who changed many lifestyle factors at once.
Potential risks and questions to discuss with a healthcare professional include:
- Long term impact on bone mineral density, especially if you already have osteopenia, as in the 2025 nutritionist case
- Changes in LDL cholesterol and other lipid markers over many months or years
- Nutrient gaps if you avoid certain animal foods like seafood or organ meats
- Social and psychological strain of maintaining a very restrictive plan
In the DEXA scan example, the small decline in bone mineral density over six weeks was enough to raise concern in someone with a prior diagnosis of osteopenia, even though the timeframe was short (Chief Nutrition). This does not prove that carnivore will weaken your bones, but it is a reminder to monitor more than just weight and energy.
You also need to remember that anecdotal reports, even detailed ones, are not the same as large clinical trials. They can guide your questions and help set expectations, but they cannot guarantee safety or specific results for you.
How to assess if carnivore is right for you
If you are curious about your own potential carnivore diet before and after, it helps to approach the experiment thoughtfully rather than jumping in blindly.
You can:
-
Write down your “before” in detail
Include weight, waist measurement, energy levels, medications, digestive symptoms, sleep quality, and mood. Be specific. -
Set a realistic trial period
Many of the reported changes happened within 30 to 90 days. You might pick 30 days as a first checkpoint with an option to extend. -
Plan your version of carnivore
Decide which animal foods you will include. Many people do best starting with beef, lamb, eggs, and some seafood. You can add or remove dairy depending on your tolerance. -
Monitor your body and labs
If possible, get baseline blood work and, if you have a history of bone issues, discuss a DEXA scan with your doctor. Recheck key markers after your trial. -
Stay flexible
If certain symptoms worsen or you feel unwell, adjust your food choices or consider a less strict low‑carb approach rather than forcing yourself to stay fully carnivore.
Key takeaways
Carnivore diet before and after experiences can be powerful. People have reported weight loss, reduced cravings, better blood pressure and blood sugar, calmer digestion, and improvements in energy, sleep, and pain, sometimes within weeks (Chief Nutrition, The Primal).
At the same time, you need to look beyond dramatic photos or headlines. Pay attention to lab results, bone health, and how sustainable the diet feels in your real life. The most useful comparison is not between you and someone else’s story, but between your own “before” and your carefully measured “after.”
About the Author
